One writer thinks Mark Prior deserves the Cy Young, while another acknowledges Kenny Rogers' performance.
There are conflicting views on how much run support A's pitcher Tim Hudson has received this season.
Esteban Loaiza has notched 17 wins, including a big one over the Yankees in New York last night.
For the first time in a long time, a Cy Young Award might be handed to a reliever -- and he might deserve it.
Breaking down the races for the MVPs and Cy Youngs along with several other individual awards.