Eddie Murray was considered a Hall of Famer long before he retired. There is still some debate whether Jim Thome, when his playing days are done, is worthy of Cooperstown. Their numbers are quite similar, probably more than you might think.
Whether you're an empiricist or an intuitionist, your best choice for AL MVP is Derek Jeter.
Rob Neyer's readers voice their opinions about his last column regarding the relative worth of hitting and pitching prospects.
There was plenty of debate about Trevor Hoffman, Jon Lieber and David Eckstein in Rob Neyer's mailbag.
There was plenty of debate about Sean Burroughs, Craig Biggio and Bernie Williams.
There was plenty of debate about Triple Crown threats, Casey Stengel and Jimmy Rollins.
There was plenty of debate about the list of all-time franchise players. So is Barry Bonds better than Junior?
Here are five of the more intriguing storylines as we head into spring training.
There was plenty of debate about the greatest-throwing outfielders in major league history.
When it comes to drafting pitchers, collegians have an edge. But that may be missing the point.
Sabermetrics – pioneered by Bill James years ago – has put baseball on an almost scientific footing.